Subhashish Bhadra
Principal, Investments

The Appropriate Use of Digital Identity: Why We Invested in a Three-Region Research Alliance

May 7, 2019

In the past decade alone, more than 110 countries have initiated identification schemes. These programs are often implemented with an initial use case, such as the delivery of subsidies. Over time, however, the issued ID is used for many other uses such as paying taxes, opening bank accounts, entering the education system, accessing critical medication, or even participating in sports competitions.

Expansion in use cases depends on a number of factors such as ease of use, whether the ID is seen as credible, etc. Such expansion of use cases also creates a risk of mission creep — i.e. that the ID is used for purposes different from the original intent, and sometimes in a way that is disempowering for individuals. In the absence of adequate legislative or judicial oversight, mission creep can create risks for those very individuals that an identity is supposed to empower.

By their very nature, digital identity systems collect some data about individuals in order to provide access to certain services. This immediately raises two interrelated questions. First, how much data should the system collect? Second, what services should it be tied to? While courts have sometimes stepped in and used the legal principle of proportionality to address these two issues, the appropriate use of digital identity has yet to be thought through satisfactorily. This decision is inherently difficult to make, and no single approach — be it economic, legal, or ethical — is likely to provide an adequate answer. For example, a purely economic approach might end up including too many use cases, because it ignores the unquantifiable risks to privacy and state power.

In the absence of any widely-accepted thinking on this issue, we run the risk of digital identity systems suffering from mission creep, that is being made mandatory or being used for an ever-expanding set of services. We believe this creates several risks. First, people may be excluded from services if they do not have a digital identity or because it malfunctions. Second, this approach creates a wider digital footprint that can be used to create a profile of an individual, sometimes without consent. This can increase privacy risk. Third, this approach increases the power of institutions versus individuals and can be used as rationale to intentionally deny services, especially to vulnerable or persecuted groups.

Three exceptional research groups have undertaken the effort of answering this complex and important question. Over the next six months, these think tanks will conduct independent research, as well as involve experts from across the globe. Based in South America, Africa, and Asia, these institutions represent the collective wisdom and experiences of three very distinct geographies in emerging markets. While drawing on their local context, this research effort is globally oriented. The think tanks will create a set of recommendations and tools that can be used by stakeholders to engage with digital identity systems in any part of the world.

We are grateful that the following organizations will help develop our collective understanding on the appropriate use of digital identity and its limits through a multi-faceted approach:

  • The Institute for Technology & Society (ITS) — a non-profit organization, based in Brazil, with a mission to ensure that Brazil and other emerging markets respond creatively and appropriately to the opportunities provided by technology in the digital age, and that the potential benefits are broadly shared across society. Through its own research and in partnership with other institutions, ITS Rio analyzes the legal, social, economic, and cultural dimensions of technology and advocates for public policies and private practices that protect privacy, freedom of expression, and access to knowledge.
  • The Centre for Intellectual Property and Information Technology Law (CIPIT) — an academic think tank based at Strathmore Law School in Nairobi, Kenya. Research at CIPIT addresses emerging issues that have continent-wide impact. CIPIT provides an African voice for research networks in emerging markets, ensuring visibility of the local, region, and continental context that is unique to Africa. Ultimately, CIPIT strives to prove that Africa can grow and support a world-class academic research centre in matters of intellectual property and IT law.
  • The Centre for Internet and Society (CIS) — a non-profit organization, based in India, that undertakes interdisciplinary research on internet and digital technologies from policy and academic perspectives. The research at CIS seeks to understand the reconfiguration of social processes and structures through the Internet and digital media technologies, and vice versa. Through its diverse initiatives, CIS explores, intervenes in, and advances contemporary discourse and regulatory practices around internet, technology, and society in India, and elsewhere.

This research will use a collaborative and iterative process. The researchers will put out some ideas every few weeks, with the objective of seeking thoughts, questions, and feedback from various stakeholders. They will participate in several digital rights and identity events across the globe over the next several months. They will also organize webinars to seek input from and present their interim findings to interested communities from across the globe. Each of these provide an opportunity for you to provide your thoughts and help this research program provide an independent, rigorous, transparent, and holistic answer to the question of when it’s appropriate for digital identity to be used. We need a diversity of viewpoints and collaborative dissent to help solve the most pressing issues of our times.

At the conclusion, the research alliance will present its findings and point of view online for all to access, accompanied by a set of tools that can assist with decision making in digital identity design and implementation.

This work aligns with Omidyar Network’s continued commitment to help norm Good ID. We believe all ID must be Good ID — inclusive, offers significant personal value, and empowers individuals with privacy, security, and control. We invest in research alliances like this one to bring new evidence about what constitutes Good ID in practice into the decision-making process and to address exclusion, discrimination, surveillance, consent, and other key issues of our time.

BACK TO BLOG
Discussion
ChrisEved ChrisEved Chris Stapleton Tour 2020 at google

Chris Stapleton is my favourite country singer. His strong voice takes me away from all issues of this planet and I start enjoy my life and listen songs created by his mind. Now he is on a All-American Road Show Tour started in May of 2019. The concerts scheduled for this year, up to the second of November. Ticket prices are moderate and available for all men and women with different income. If you love contry music, then you must visit at least one of his concert. All tour dates are available at the Chris Stapleton tour Lafayette. Open the website and make yourself familiar with all Chris Stapleton concerts in 2019!

Reply
BreakEved BreakEved Breaking Benjamin Tour Dates at google

Breaking Benjamin is my favourite band of 90s. Breaking Benjamin had so many hit songs! The ones I remember are 'The Diary of Jane', 'Tourniquet' and their hit 'So Cold'. These are real songs, not fake like today! And it is awesome that Breaking Benjamin have a tour in 2019! So I'm going to attend their concert in 2019. The full list is here: https://breakingbenjaminconcerts.com. Open the page and maybe we can even visit one of the Benjamin's together!

Reply
BreakEved BreakEved Breaking Benjamin Concerts at google

Breaking Benjamin is my favourite band of 90s. They had so many hit songs! The ones I remember are 'The Diary of Jane', 'Tourniquet' and, of course their hit 'So Cold'. These are real songs, not fake like today! And it is sooo good that Breaking Benjamin have a tour in 2020! And I'm going to visit Breaking Benjamin concert in 2019. The concert setlist is here: Breaking Benjamin tour. Check it out and maybe we can even visit one of the concerts together!

Reply
StazaimTut StazaimTut займы на карту мгновенно без отказов круглосуточно - mega-zaimer.ru at google

Взять быстрый займ на сайте MEGA-ZAIMER.RU Молодые семьи привыкли активно брать займы в паутине. В интернете есть большое количество веб-сайтов, которые предоставляют возможность брать финансы в займ online. Сегодня не 90ые и нет необходимости посещать банк, чтобы взять займ. Вы можете зайти на mega-zaimer.ru и оформить заявку на получение займа. На данный момент на ресурсе есть разные варианты займов. Вы можете взять займ онлайн на карту срочно без отказа при этом сумма займа может быть 2000 рублей, а может быть 300000 рублей. Чтобы вы могли получить финансы, вам надо иметь банковскую карту. Оптимально, чтобы эта кредитка была одного из банка РФ. В этом случае перевод будет произведен моментально. Необходимо отдельно отметить и о том, что вы можете оформить займ в интересующих Вас МФО. Как вариант может быть, как E-Капуста, так и Платиза, а также есть микрокредиты на банковскую карту. Вы можете без каких-то сложностей получить займ фактически за 10 минут. Вам надо будет заполнить анкету и при надобности ответить на вопросы консультанта. Для получения займа необходимо указать личные данные и номер телефона, на который может поступить код активации. Одобрение проходит невероятно быстро. Необходимо отметить и то, что все компании предоставляют гарантировано деньги. На ресурсе подобраны МКК, у которых низкие процентные ставки. Несмотря на то, что виртуальные займы на карту без отказа получить в банковских учреждениях ныне тяжело, взять займ в одном из МФО очень просто. Вы можете взять денежные активы на срок от 5 до 30 суток с возможностью продления займа. На https://mega-zaimer.ru/mikrozaim-za-5-minut/ у вас есть шанс выбрать МКК, которое подойдёт именно Вам! На сайте есть каталог лучших компаний. К сожалению, в жизни могут быть незапланированные расходы, и онлайн займ может быть очень кстати. Если вы хотите получить займ на карту онлайн следует сделать выбор среди МФО на ресурсе. Это позволит вам моментально решить любые вопросы с незапланированными расходами. Сегодня не все могут получать отличную зарплату, из-за чего в любое время могут появиться денежные вопросы. Отдельно необходимо сказать, что у любого сервиса есть своя служба поддержки. Это невероятно важно, ведь при получении займа могут возникнуть любые вопросы, будь это финансовые или технические. Решать такие вопросы стоит сразу. Если вам потребовались денежные средства на лечение, но в банковском учреждении вы не сможете получить их, а у родственников брать не выходит, предлагаем обратиться в МФО. Вы легко сможете получить конкретную сумму и решить свои финансовые вопросы.

Reply
XenSeaps XenSeaps Download Xender app for Windows at google

In this age people share photo so many times a day they need a decent and 100% safe app to perform this task. Xender is one of them. With this app you can send your files everywhere you want, from your computer to iPhone and vice versa. You can download Xender app for free!

Reply
ChrisEved ChrisEved Chris Stapleton Concerts at google

Chris Stapleton is my favourite US contry singer. His voice takes me away from all troubles of this world and I can enjoy my life and listen songs created by his voice. Now the singer is on a All-American Road Show Tour started in May of 2019. The concerts scheduled for the whole 2019, up to the second of November. Tickets are available for all men and women with different income. If you love contry music, then you must visit at least one Chris' concert. All tour dates are available at the Chris Stapleton tour Greensboro. Open the website and make yourself familiar with all powerful Chris Stapleton concerts in 2019!

Reply
MiraEved MiraEved Miranda Lambert Concerts at google

Miranda Lambert is my favourite US contry singer. She is young, beautiful and charming female in her 30s. Her voice takes me away from all issues of this world so I can enjoy my life and listen songs created by her. Now the singer is on a Roadside Bars & Pink Guitars Tour started in September of 2019 featuring Tenille Townes, Ashley McBride and others. The concerts scheduled for the whole 2019, up to the end of November. Ticket prices are moderate and available for all men and women with different income. If you love country music as mush as I, then you must visit at least one of her concert. All tour dates are available at the Miranda Lambert tour 2020. Open the website and make yourself familiar with all powerful Miranda Lambert concerts in 2020!

Reply
sopogsqwe sopogsqwe Действие обуви из ПВХ и ЭВА at google

Обувная здание «ВВС» основана в 1996 г., и является одним из ведущих предприятий Ростовской области по производству качественной обуви из пластиката и ЭВА. Обувь изготавливается для итальянском оборудовании «Nuova Zarine» и «Wintech». Хорошая техническая оснащенность, нынешний дизайн, высокая квалификация работников позволяет исключать обувь высокого качества по низким ценам. Технология изготовления и применяемые материалы обеспечивают эластичность, легкость и высокую прочность нашей обуви. Она удобна и практична. Вся обувь сертифицирована и имеет санитарно-эпидемиологическое заключение. Обувь выпускается для безвыездно возрастные группы и предназначена ради работы и отдыха. Мы будем рады любоваться вас в числе в числе наших партнеров и сделаем все, чтобы наше сотрудничество стало взаимовыгодным и долгосрочным. галоша контакты contacts https://sapog-vvs.ru/

Reply
Be the first to comment
It looks like there's some information missing
By clicking, you agree to the Terms and Conditions

Announcement

LuxTrust and Cambridge Blockchain Announce Private Beta for Privacy-Protecting Identity Platform

LuxTrust S.A. and Cambridge Blockchain Inc.,announced the private beta-testing phase for privacy-protecting European identity platform IDKEEP.

READ ON

Announcement

The American Geographical Society Selected to Lead Global Conversation on the Ethical Dimensions of New Geospatial Data and Technologies

The American Geographical Society (AGS) has been awarded a grant by Omidyar Network to launch a world-wide conversation on the ethics of geospatial technologies.

READ ON

Article

How Omidyar Network Aims to Reimagine Capitalism

Mike Kubzansky shares insights about our refreshed strategy in a recent interview with The Business of Giving.

READ ON