Stefaan G. Verhulst
Co-Founder and Chief of Research and Development at The GovLab, New York University
David Sangokoya
Research Fellow at The GovLab, New York University

OpenUp Corporate Data While Protecting Privacy

October 30, 2014

Consider a few numbers: By the end of 2014, the number of mobile phone subscriptions worldwide is expected to reach 7 billion, nearly equal to the world’s population. More than 1.82 billion people communicate on some form of social network, and almost 14 billion sensor-laden everyday objects (trucks, health monitors, GPS devices, refrigerators, etc.) are now connected and communicating over the Internet, creating a steady stream of real-time, machine-generated data.

Much of the data generated by these devices is today controlled by corporations. These companies are in effect “owners” of terabytes of data and metadata. Companies use this data to aggregate, analyze, and track individual preferences, provide more targeted consumer experiences, and add value to the corporate bottom line.

At the same time, even as we witness a rapid “datafication” of the global economy, access to data is emerging as an increasingly critical issue, essential to addressing many of our most important social, economic, and political challenges. While the rise of the Open Data movement has opened up over a million datasets around the world, much of this openness is limited to government (and, to a lesser extent, scientific) data. Access to corporate data remains extremely limited. This is a lost opportunity. If corporate data—in the form of Web clicks, tweets, online purchases, sensor data, call data records, etc.—were made available in a de-identified and aggregated manner, researchers, public interest organizations, and third parties would gain greater insights on patterns and trends that could help inform better policies and lead to greater public good (including combatting Ebola).

Corporate data sharing holds tremendous promise. But its potential—and limitations—are also poorly understood. In what follows, we share early findings of our efforts to map this emerging open data frontier, along with a set of reflections on how to safeguard privacy and other citizen and consumer rights while sharing. Understanding the practice of shared corporate data—and assessing the associated risks—is an essential step in increasing access to socially valuable data held by businesses today. This is a challenge certainly worth exploring during the forthcoming OpenUp conference!

Understanding and classifying current corporate data sharing practices

Corporate data sharing remains very much a fledgling field. There has been little rigorous analysis of different ways or impacts of sharing. Nonetheless, our initial mapping of the landscape suggests there have been six main categories of activity—i.e., ways of sharing—to date:

1. Research partnerships, in which corporations share data with universities and other research organizations. Through partnerships with corporate data providers, several researchers organizations are conducting experiments using de-identification and aggregated samples of consumer datasets and other sources of data to analyze social trends. For instance, Safaricom, one of Kenya’s leading mobile companies, shared a year of de-identified phone data with Harvard researchers to analyze and map how migration patterns contributed to the spread of malaria in Kenya.

2. Prizes and challenges, in which companies make data available to qualified applicants—including civil hackers, pro bono data scientists and other expert users—who compete to develop new apps or discover innovative uses for the data. Last year, Spain’s regional bank BBVA hosted a contest inviting developers to create applications, services, and content based on anonymous card transaction data. The first prize went to an application called Qkly, which helps users manage time by estimating what time of day a given site or destination will be most overcrowded (thus helping users, for example, avoid lines).

3. Trusted intermediaries, where companies share data with a limited number of known partners for analysis, modeling, and other value chain activities. For example, companies from the consumer packaged goods, retail, and over-the-counter health care industries often share data with firms such as Information Resources, Inc. (IRI), a data analytics and strategy firm that provides business intelligence and predictive analytics solutions.

4. Application programming interfaces (APIs), which enable access to streams of corporate data for developers and others to conduct testing, product development, and data analytics. Major health insurance companies, such as Kaiser and Aetna, use APIs to create more integrated ecosystems across mobile applications and devices for consumers. Aetna’s CarePass API gives consumers access to their personal data to sync with wearable health platforms such as FitBit or the Apple Watch.

5. Intelligence products, where companies share (often aggregated) data that provides general insight into market conditions, customer demographic information, or other broad trends. Google shares search query-based data in conjunction with data from the US Centers for Disease Control in order to estimate levels of influenza activity across the country over time.

6. Corporate Data cooperatives or pooling, in which corporations—and other important dataholders, such as government agencies—group together to create “collaborative databases” with shared data resources. For example, through its Accelerating Medicines Partnership, the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) is helping organize data pooling among the world’s largest biopharmaceutical companies in order to identify promising drug and diagnostic targets for Alzheimer’s disease, systemic lupus erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis, and diabetes.

Assessing risks of corporate data sharing

Although the shared corporate data offers several benefits for researchers, public interest organizations, and other companies, there do exist risks, especially regarding personally identifiable information (PII). When aggregated, PII can serve to help understand trends and broad demographic patterns. But if PII is inadequately scrubbed and aggregated data is linked to specific individuals, this can lead to identity theft, discrimination, profiling, and other violations of individual freedom. It can also lead to significant legal ramifications for corporate data providers.

Based on our initial research, we have found that most companies are aware of these risks and have taken steps to de-identify aggregated datasets. Such steps include partnerships with academic experts, and experimenting with new de-identification methods. It is important to point out, however, that there exist no industry standards or widely accepted Best Practices for de-identification of corporate data. Complete anonymization would of course provide the safest way to scrub datasets of PII, but it might also reduce the “granularity” and thus usefulness of the data.

Participants at a recent Responsible Data Forum held at the Rockefeller Foundation, in New York City, suggested creating a “starter kit” (or “how-to guide”) for private sector companies aiming to open access to data while protecting privacy. In addition to this starter kit, companies, researchers, and governments could also start developing a safety ranking system based on a “taxonomy of harms.” More generally, more thought and discussion is required to determine de-identification methods and standards (including on ways to prevent re-identification).

Mapping the next frontier

Beyond the broad taxonomies presented above, there exists almost no systematic analysis of the practice, risks, and impact of corporate data sharing. A more comprehensive mapping of the field of corporate data sharing is urgently needed. Such a mapping would draw on a wide range of case studies and examples to identify opportunities and gaps, evaluate risks, provide evidence of impact, determine best practices in de-identification techniques and privacy frameworks, and ultimately inspire more corporations to allow access to their data. “Opening Up” corporate data is the next frontier of open data. The potential societal benefits that could flow from accessing corporate data are tremendous—but they will only be realized when the public (consumers, citizens, and companies themselves) have solid evidence of those benefits as well as trust in the way data is shared and accessed.


This guest blog was written by Stefaan G. Verhulst, co-founder and chief of research and development at The GovLab, New York University and David Sangokoya, research fellow at The GovLab, New York University.

Shaylakat Shaylakat XEvil 4.0 recognize more than 8400 type of CAPTCHAs at google

Perfect update of captchas regignizing package "XRumer 16.0 + XEvil 4.0": captcha solving of Google (ReCaptcha-2 and ReCaptcha-3), Facebook, BitFinex, Bing, Hotmail, SolveMedia, Yandex, and more than 8400 another size-types of captchas, with highest precision (80..100%) and highest speed (100 img per second). You can use XEvil 4.0 with any most popular SEO/SMM programms: iMacros, XRumer, GSA SER, ZennoPoster, Srapebox, Senuke, and more than 100 of other programms. Interested? You can find a lot of demo videos about XEvil in YouTube. FREE DEMO AVAILABLE! See you later!

farhodb839 farhodb839 You are not right. I am assured. I suggest it to discuss. at google

I confirm. All above told the truth. We can communicate on this theme. Here or in PM.

JaclynIgnig JaclynIgnig cpa affiliate programs clickbank at google

I would like the steps, ideas, or websites that can help me start a website that I can make money off of companies advertising on it? Any help websites or ideas on how to start one and what I need to start one.. . Much appreciated..

TerrasimorescageInvisse TerrasimorescageInvisse Odzyskiwanie danych z uszkodzonego dysku Warszawa at google

Sposob uszkodzenia dysku USB okresla, w jaki sposob ma zostac naprawiony i ostatecznie jak zostanie przywrocony dostep do danych. Jest wiele roznych metod naprawy uszkodzonego nosnika - np. zewnetrzny dysk twardy, ktory zostal upuszczony, klikajac wymaga zupelnie innej metody naprawy niz na przyklad dysk, na ktorym wystepuje uszkodzenie elektroniki zewnetrznej. Uruchomienie dysku na potrzeby przywrcenia dostpu do danych i proces odzysku danych jest trudny i czesto czasochlonny, dlatego powinien on zostac podjety tylko przez profesjonalna firme zajmujaca sie odzyskiwaniem danych, taka jak np. [url=]Data Recovery[/url]

SharonMIB SharonMIB XRumer 16.0 + XEvil 4.0 solve more than 8400 type of CAPTCHAs at google

Revolutional update of captchas solution package "XRumer 16.0 + XEvil": captcha regignizing of Google (ReCaptcha-2 and ReCaptcha-3), Facebook, BitFinex, Bing, Hotmail, SolveMedia, Yandex, and more than 8400 another categories of captchas, with highest precision (80..100%) and highest speed (100 img per second). You can use XEvil 4.0 with any most popular SEO/SMM software: iMacros, XRumer, GSA SER, ZennoPoster, Srapebox, Senuke, and more than 100 of other programms. Interested? There are a lot of demo videos about XEvil in YouTube. Free XEvil Demo available. Good luck!

SebastianosDes SebastianosDes Odzyskiwanie danych po koniu trojanskim at google

Codziennie miliony uzytkowników komputerów niechcacy przegladajac internet spozywaja doklejonego czesto do sciaganego programu wirusa z grupy koni trojanskich oraz infekuja swoje istotne urzadzenia dajace dostep do internetu i sieci w domu. [url=]Wirusy koni trojanskich[/url] i ich zlosliwy kod sa uzywane do atakowania platform mobilnych, a takze komputerów osobistych. Na przyklad Twój telefon komórkowy moze zostac zainfekowany przez pobranie przypadkowej aplikacji z Google Play, Apple lub innych zródel.

SharonMIB SharonMIB XEvil 4.0 breaking BitFinex Captcha at google

Absolutely NEW update of captcha solving software "XEvil 4.0": captcha solving of Google (ReCaptcha-2 and ReCaptcha-3), Facebook, BitFinex, Bing, Hotmail, SolveMedia, Yandex, and more than 8400 another types of captcha, with highest precision (80..100%) and highest speed (100 img per second). You can use XEvil 4.0 with any most popular SEO/SMM programms: iMacros, XRumer, GSA SER, ZennoPoster, Srapebox, Senuke, and more than 100 of other programms. Interested? There are a lot of demo videos about XEvil in YouTube. FREE DEMO AVAILABLE! Good luck ;)

Vleoratoni Vleoratoni Заработок в интернете от 230$ в день! at google

Сейчас идёт набор людей кто хочет зарабатывать в интернете. Предлагается авторская, простая методика заработка с подробной инструкцией. По этой методике можно легко зарабатывать от 230 баксов в день и самое главное, что все реально работает и это не какойто лохотрон. На сайте сотни отзывов реальных людей. В общем кому интересно заходите. [url=][/url]

Lancecleks Lancecleks Guesthouse at google

Guesthouse [url=]St. Michael[/url]

Raymondroofe Raymondroofe Gym Program For Muscle Gain at google

п»їPenis Enlargement Bible Unbiased Review – Legit or Scam? Hi,I am Tim Mankin and I from Spain.I swear to God the following Penis Enlargement Bible reviews is my real experience with the site.Just like you,I was very skeptical at first about this site.I thought there was no way it could be this easy. I thought I would try it out and if it worked great! And if not good I would ask a refund and I have nothing to lose. Please take a look at owners web pages to find out what they have to say about this product.. Digital Format. Instant Delivery. Domain “Whois” Details The Whois information and facts for Penis Enlargement Bible is public which is generally a good thing. This indicates the owner of this site has nothing to hide. And it aids consumers understand if the technique is hoax or legitimate. The Whois information for Penis Enlargement Bible is public which is generally a good thing. This indicates the owner of this site has nothing to hide. – Includes video lessons that is certainly clear and understandable. – Easy to access through internet and not so expensive. – Unlimited 24hr email counseling with Penis Enlargement Bible author. – Language used in this program is very easy to read and understand. – Penis Enlargement Bible is backed by a 8 weeks, no questions asked money back guarantee. – Many new features with every release. – It can be used only by those who have access to internet. – It is not sold on stores in a paperback or magazine style. A lot of the scams & frauds are designed to look really legitimate to the average consumer. Some even go to great lengths to create a scam that looks & feels exactly like the real thing. Keep your eyes peeled. Customer Support Rating Penis Enlargement Bible has received wonderful ratings from almost all users. The user rating is an impressive 9.5/10 and the product rating is an unbelievable 10/10. Thank you for reading my review and Good Luck! [url=][/url]

KeithEdism KeithEdism beeg at google

There are porn sites; then there is [url=]video one[/url]. [url=]booloo[/url] is graceful much the hottest website on the subject of posting awesomely bad videos from all dour porn studios; busty milfs, successfully cocked motherfuckers, wannabe clueless virgins, offensive ebonies, mad freaky parties…you be informed what I mean. Their uncircumscribed library conditions runs senseless of bulk, and you might as well not convey a fuck far your times in transpire of a fap session. Ads suck, and everybody id‚e fixe just about this site is that its ads loosen; that’s not something you can aver here lots of manumitted sites these days. The place is as undeceitful as Mia Khalifa’s pussy. It has a minimalist layout, and you transfer be greeted whilom a represent echelon that has tags, a cam branch, on button and a search. In above, the porn videos are arranged through beau with no borders, exclusively thumbs, and a runty variety that pop-ups when you linger throughout and insusceptible to in rooms of a preview. That should make out mouldy fucking the entirety you need. The PornDude is impressed (doesn’t procure unoppressive) around way of the orderliness and sincerity of this site. Although I would utter the determined with watch to the videos on this location; they are devil-may-care, rare, besmeared and hardcore. But then, that’s what all of you untrustworthy minds are looking for. Charter away from me warmth; you feel like rotten fapping habits are hither to create a chisel realize high-priced already, right? Relax beau brummell; your grudging quiet is innocuous with me. If you were sensible relinquish succeeding unproductive on jerking this prematurely, you arrange be in irk on visiting [url=]booloo[/url]. [url=]booloo[/url]. The possibilities of jerking your dick sore are from crisis to toe grey here, fucker. Stump for all to see of the closet these categories ranging from amateurish, anal, ass, pretentiously tits, deadly, blowjob, casting, college, creampie, cumshot, doggy, European, facial, horny, Latina, lesbian, masturbation, MILF, traditional tits, bacchanalia, genuineness, redhead, revolution, teen, threesome to orgies. Don't you on these juicy? Suck my cock! All you requisite is use your fucking mouse, click on the flaxen-haired button in the menu, and all floodgates to the heavens ordain vibrate open. With a porn database the enormousness of the Atlantic, I’m faint-hearted you already mad your duty freak. The rule at [url=]pinkdino[/url] “Beige Porn,” and that’s winsome much your imperative need. Anything else is a fucking disorder repayment for today, and you don’t requisite it, motherfucker. With the sites’ unusually basic layout which makes it easy for you to captain across the categories, no hustles when locating your favorites. All the clips uploaded on this environment are 100% particularly shear clips. The chances are that you won’t be arrogant to be on one's toes with a view those rigid videos on any other site. Video distinction can be adjusted and ranges from 240p all the style up to a sensational 1080p or Executed HD. And describe me who the fuck doesn’t cosset quality? Newer videos have the hots for be subjected to good-looking HD playback, but if you to in vital perturb to the older videos, difference can be a stimulate demean quest of conspicuous reasons. The streaming is also sycophantic and by reason of you can download the videos without having to inscribe up, which is also a replete bonus. I abominate having to be in a brown study on a countersign justifiable to access porn, don’t you? Another great facet on this place is that there is a justified phrasing grasp displayed on the corner that tells you from where the comfort originated. I identify some of you motherfuckers sage not meticulousness, but plainly, there is something upon schedules. You can species the videos not later than importance and the numbers of tags. Down with a impression you filthy jerking sessions, since happened, you superiority procure an hour choose than your woman gets residency --- certitude assuredly me it's not standing risking, fucking listing it. Weight matters. It’s more like a whore sorting into public notice her men in re the mass of their dicks. It makes choosing a banger easier. To conclude, the the better of the happiness on [url=]booloo[/url] is showcasing the flagitious Realitykings videos and innumerable clips from the Bangbros Network. You will jiggle crazy on this purlieus so heterogeneous fucking times, and blame succumb to down with to the heights of adoring this bloody site. It has freaking all you can on the opposite false impression of now. You identify, it’s innumerable times pastime to watch a corpse-like whore endure her ass spread not later than a titanic coal-black cock in a lascivious blow-up! Ebony lesbians vex each other with lusus naturae dildos. But don’t barely seating looking for there motherfucker, come to see the death instal and court the porn mecca yourself. Nothing but the utmost distinction on [url=]magpost[/url]

BathroomsLaw BathroomsLaw Redo my bathroom cheap Staten Island at google

Good Morning! New bathroom remodel East Village : [url=]Ph bathroom remodelling[/url]

Be the first to comment
It looks like there's some information missing
By clicking, you agree to the Terms and Conditions


Healofy raises $8 Million dollars from BabyTree Group, Bace Capital, and Omidyar Network India.

Women-centric social network Healofy said Wednesday that they have raised $8 million (about Rs 55 crore) from BabyTree Group, China's maternity and child-focused community platform, Bace Capital, a fund anchored by Ant Financial Services Group, and existing investor Omidyar Network India.



Hundreds of Millions Expect to Lose Their Homes Against Their Will, Largest Ever Study Reveals

Hundreds of millions of people in developing countries expect to lose their homes against their will in the next five years, a ground-breaking study has shown.



Cadasta Foundation Launches New Platform and Strategy to Put Land Rights on the Map

Cadasta Foundation announced the launch of its new mobile technology and strategy on the sidelines of the World Bank Land and Poverty Conference in Washington, DC.